Overhead vs underground lines advantages and disadvantages of. Mar 17, 2017 underground transmission system advantages. We compared public reactions to grid expansion at two project sites in germany. Underground information about burying highvoltage transmission lines highvoltage transmission lines are a reliable, low cost, easily maintained and established method to transport bulk electricity across long distances. An underground circuit typically costs anywhere from 1 to 2. It will cost more to place lines underground than overhead. In recent years, the evolution of underground cables with extruded insulations, like cross linked polyethylene xlpe, and their enhanced performance has shifted the focus of attention from the installation of ordinary overhead lines to the installation of underground extrahigh voltage ehv and high voltage hv transmission circuits. The purpose of this document is to provide information about the technical merits and challenges associated with undergrounding high voltage electricity lines, compared with installing overhead lines. Comparison of overhead and underground transmission lines name. Difference overhead transmission vs underground transmission. Replacing overhead with underground lines will also change other characteristics of the line and connected power system. This limits the use of cables for high voltage levels. When it comes to both overhead and underground distribution and transmission lines, all may not be as it seems.
We estimated effects on public risk expectations, attitudes, and protest behavior. Some estimates put the costs of underground power cables at as much as four times the cost of the overhead option. Placing transmission cables underground is generally only considered when above ground is not a. To minimize a large charging current produced in high voltage cables, the length of the cable should be minimized. Insulated cables, underground surveying and excavation, splicing vaults and concrete. Underground cables are installed in concrete encased pvc duct banks. Replacing all the overhead lines in a state transmission and distribution with underground lines is probably not possible or distribution with underground lines is probably not possible or desirable. In terms of reliability, capability, cost, construction impacts and land use, overhead lines do have advantages when compared to underground cables. Overhead transmission o an overhead power line is a structure used in electric power transmission and distribution to transmit electrical energy along large distances. Underground transmission cables can be an alternative to the more common above ground transmission lines. Underground electric transmission lines introduction this overview contains information about electric transmission lines which are installed underground, rather than overhead on poles or towers.
Advantages disadvantages underground and overhead transmission. Overhead transmission lines mea is often asked why it doesnt simply bury its transmission lines. What is the difference between an overhead cable and an. All relevant data about these lines were offered by fault identification of overhead transmission lines terminated with underground cables a. Construction impacts burying transmission lines has more environmental impacts than placing them overhead. Transmission lines primarily use bare aluminum conductors suspended between supporting towers using insulator strings made of glass or solid polymer coated fiberglass. Since the phases of a highvoltage overhead transmission line must be spaced further apart to ensure proper insulation, a highvoltage line will have a higher inductance than a lowvoltage line. However, a significant benefit of undergrounding cables is the reduction in visual impact. This current flows onto the protected line or cable from all terminals. Difference between underground cable and overhead cable. A literature search on the costs and benefits of overhead and underground utilities, including the societal cost as a result of collisions of highway vehicles with above ground utilities. However, when long transmission overhead lines or underground cables are present in the system, the effects of the charging current caused by the shunt capacitance need to be considered. One was an underground cable project, the other an overhead line project. Overhead lines have more advantages than underground lines.
Fault identification of overhead transmission lines. Comparison of overhead and underground transmission cables. How much more expensive this is depends on the subsoil and the number of intersections with other infrastructure such as motorways, waterways or railways. Starting from 1967 in russia, and also in the usa and canada, overhead lines for voltage of 765 kv were built.
Underground lines are protected from some, but not all, types of storm damage. Protection of mixed overhead and underground cable lines. Underground power transmission has a significantly higher cost and. However, it may be necessary to lay cables underground if there is no viable overhead corridor, such as in densely populated areas or near airports. According to the may 2011 paper underground electric transmission lines published by the public service commission of wisconsin, the estimated cost for constructing underground transmission lines ranges from 4 to 14 times more expensive than overhead lines of the same voltage and same distance. Here in this article we are going to discuss about comparison between overhead lines and underground cables. The purpose of this document is to provide information about the technical merits and challenges associated with undergrounding high voltage electricity lines, compared with installing overhead lines technical issues of undergrounding high voltage transmission lines photo credit. Comparison of overhead and underground transmission lines 1. An overhead cable is a cable for the transmission of information, laid on utility poles.
There are two types of transmission line conductors. You can also follow us in other social medias to gain. Overhead powerlines and underground cables form 8121. Hence capacitance of underground cables is much more than that of overhead lines. What is the main difference between transmission lines and. For long distance transmission over headline cable can be used. From above discussion, underground transmission lines are less common while underground distribution lines are more common. Costs an underground 230 kv line costs 10 to 15 times the cost of an overhead line due to time, materials, process, the need to include. But it is not just about the installation, as maintenance and repair is also cheaper with overhead lines. Cables, however, have differing characteristics than overhead lines that must be factored into design, ratings, switching, reactive compensation, operation.
Since the spacing between lines in buried cables is very small, series inductance of cables is much smaller than the inductance of overhead lines. Altalink will consider the use of underground transmission technology on a project by project basis. Technical issues of undergrounding high voltage transmission. Overhead telephone and cable tv lines are common in north america. The underground transmission systems are safer than the overhead transmission system. Underground cables have different technical requirements than overhead lines and have different environmental impacts. Comparison of high voltage cables with existing overhead. A typical 345,000v transmission line will be able to deliver no power when the line becomes about 26 miles long. It demonstrates the higher technology in developed countries for fire prevention and to make the power lines less susceptible to outages during high wind thunderstorms or heavy snow or ice storms. The transmission of electric energy can be done in alternate current or continuous current and can also be done by using underground cables or overhead lines. Charging current of cables is moredue to higher capacitance compared to overhead lines of same voltage level. Construction of transmission and distribution lines.
Overhead transmission lines shorter than 80 km 50 miles can be modeled as a series resistance and inductance, since the shunt capacitance can be neglected over short distances. Underground power cable systems new york city no overhead since 1890s singapore 100% underground the netherlands distribution 100% belgium ban on oh lines since 1992 denmark replaced six 2 kv oh lines with two new 400 kv ug cables in 1997 and 1999 december 1999 storms in france caused many. It is a frequent question for electrical engineers but not only what type of technology should be used for their project overhead line or underground cable. If the separation is small, the capacitance is more. In overhead line inductor plays major roles and in underground cable the capacitor plays major role. The most common methods for transfer of electric power are. While burying transmission lines is an intuitively desirable approach, many people dont recognize the technical difficulties. Undergrounding high voltage electricity transmission lines. The lifespan of underground lines is 30 to 35 years, about half that of overhead lines. Overhead lines are nothing but a conductor laid on the top of earth by installing transmission tower. Technical issues of undergrounding high voltage transmission lines photo credit.
Underground construction of transmission lines often costs 5 to 10 times more than overhead construction. For the longdistance transmission cable cannot be used due to their long charging current. Overhead transmission line the line consists of a 200 km overhead transmission line. By replacing overhead lines with underground cables, outages due to storms and icing will be reduced significantly in the range of one order of magnitude tenfold. Underground cables are more expensive to construct since they have to be electrically insulated and have protection against moisture, corrosion, mechanical damage and other environmental impacts from the soil. This is the primary reason why most cables are overhead.
Comparison between overhead cable and underground cable. The overhead line is similar to the typical egyptian 220 kv power line. Disadvantages of underground cables in comparision to overhead lines. This is a result of the higher costs of the cable, mainly the substantially more expensive excavation works. The cea estimated that underground system maintenance averaged 2% of system plant investment whereas overhead systems averaged 3 to 4%, or as much as twice that of underground systems. Overhead lines can be created at a lower cost than underground cables. If the soil is easy to dig, if the soil has few rocks, if the ground has no other obstacles like water pipes or telephone wires, then crews may be able to plow in cable faster and for less cost than an overhead circuit. These lines are used for electric power transportation from one. Underground circuits are safer to the public than overhead circuits. This is the case in overhead lines where two conductors are separated by several meters. The longest underground circuits at 230,000 or 345,000v are 20 miles long. They are typically referred to in literature as mixed conductor technology circuits, mixed circuits, or hybrid circuits.
An overview of maintenance procedures previous next much like overhead transmission lines, underground electrical cables and other ancillary facilities can experience problems if they arent properly maintained. To maintain clearance between the conductors and ground, supporting towers are used. These lines are used for electric power transportation from one place to the other. Charging current in long lines and highvoltage cables. Overhead lines vs underground cables full comparison. Innovation in underground cable and accessories technology has contributed to an increase in underground transmission networks projects in the last few decades. The location of the fault in overhead line in easily found.
Highvoltage hv underground ac transmission cables have significantly different electrical characteristics than overhead transmission lines. Comparison between overhead lines and underground cables. Overhead conductors, made of naked metal and suspended on insulators, are preferred over underground conductors because of the lower cost and easy maintenance. Heat generated by the cables is dissipated into the earth. Hello everyone, in this video i will discuss about 10 difference between overhead transmission system and underground transmission system. That is, while there has been a distinct trend toward the installation of more underground distribution lines, there are a number of factors that dictate the continued use of and even new installation of overhead lines. Capacity requirements for underground transmission, a large number of cables are. Underground cables are thought to provoke less public opposition than overhead lines. Damage to overhead lines is easy to locate and typically takes several hours or days to repair. The inductive reactance at 60 hz for overhead lines is typically much larger than the resistance of the line. Transmission cables use insulated conductors which. Overhead lines design main components of overhead lines.
These conductors placed at a height from the ground. Power and utility cables hang from poles on a street in hachioji. What are the advantages and disadvantages of overhead power. Overhead and underground electrical contractor magazine. Those costs must be passed along to our members through rates. A comparison of overhead line system,underground cable system. Now let us discuss the about overhead lines and their design. Most of our high voltage transmission lines are built overhead due to cost, ease of repair and environmental considerations.
In some applications overhead lines are useful in some applications underground cables are required,hence differences between overhead line system and. Jan 20, 2016 comparison of overhead and underground transmission lines 1. Installation process through various geographic areas has high difficulties, because of ground excavation. Undergrounding is the replacement of overhead cables providing electrical power or telecommunications, with underground cables. Its impacts are present during normal operation and during system transients. The article talks about how the cable technology, both for overhead and underground transmission of electrical power has gained increased attention in recent times due to changed perception of the electrical power system from the point of view of reliability, safety and economic aspects. In common terms, the laying of cables below the earth surface for purpose of transmission of electric power is known as underground transmission system. Underground cables are a viable alternative to overhead transmission lines when proper consideration is given to the many details of using these types of systems.